real-estate
Real Estate Agent Commission in New York
How much New York sellers pay in commission, from NYC co-ops to upstate homes, plus transfer taxes, the mansion tax, and the 2024 buyer-agent rule changes.
In This Article
Real Estate Agent Commission in New York
A two-bedroom co-op on the Upper West Side and a three-bedroom colonial outside Rochester can carry the same commission rate on paper. The checks look nothing alike. On a $1.4 million apartment, a 5% total fee comes to $70,000, while the same rate on a $280,000 house in Monroe County is $14,000.
That gap shapes how New York sellers talk to agents. Manhattan sellers tend to negotiate over fractions of a percent because each tenth of a point is worth thousands. Upstate sellers often care more about what the agent does for the money, since the dollar amount is smaller and the listing work looks similar.
What New York Sellers Typically Pay
Commission in New York is negotiable, and no law sets a rate. Across most of the state, total fees have historically landed somewhere around 5% to 6% of the sale price, split between the listing brokerage and the brokerage that brought the buyer. Many sellers now pay less than that, and some pay more for a full-service package with staging and heavy marketing.
The split matters as much as the total. A listing agent might charge roughly 2.5% to 3% for their own side, and the seller then decides separately whether to offer anything toward the buyer's agent. Since the 2024 changes, that second number is no longer automatic.
NYC Versus the Rest of the State
New York City runs on its own rhythm. Prices are high, so percentage rates can drift a little lower on expensive listings, and boutique brokerages compete hard for exclusive listings in Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn. Full-service firms still expect something near the traditional range on most apartments under a few million dollars.
Upstate cities like Buffalo, Syracuse, Albany, and Rochester tend to see more standard rates, partly because lower prices leave less room to cut. On Long Island and in Westchester, rates often sit between the two, with suburban sellers comparing a few agents before signing.
What the Fee Covers
A listing fee in New York usually includes pricing analysis, photography, MLS or REBNY listing syndication, showings, and negotiation through contract. In the city, it also often covers open houses run on a tight schedule and coordination with the building's managing agent. Ask for a written list before you sign, because "full service" means different things at different firms.
The 2024 NAR Settlement and Buyer Agreements
The National Association of Realtors settlement took effect in August 2024 and changed two things that matter to New York sellers. Offers of buyer-agent compensation can no longer appear on the MLS. Buyers working with an agent also have to sign a written agreement before touring homes, and that agreement spells out what their agent will be paid.
For sellers, this means the buyer-side fee is now a negotiation point inside the deal. A buyer might ask you to cover their agent's fee as part of the offer, pay it themselves, or split it with you. You can say yes, no, or meet in the middle.
How It Plays Out in Practice
Most New York sellers still agree to contribute something toward the buyer's agent, because buyers with less cash on hand would otherwise struggle to cover it. That is especially true in the outer boroughs and upstate, where buyers often stretch to reach a down payment. Some listing agents advertise a willingness to cooperate without naming a figure.
In higher Manhattan price ranges, buyers often have the cash to handle part of their own agent's fee. Expect more back-and-forth there. The written buyer agreement tells you what the buyer has already promised their agent, so ask your listing agent to find out early.
Transfer Taxes and the Mansion Tax
Commission is the biggest closing cost for most New York sellers, though taxes come close in the city. New York State charges a real estate transfer tax of 0.4% of the sale price, and the seller customarily pays it. On a $500,000 sale, that is $2,000.
New York City adds its own Real Property Transfer Tax on top. For residential sales, the city rate is 1% on sales of $500,000 or less and 1.425% above that. A $1.2 million condo sale in Queens would owe roughly $17,100 to the city plus $4,800 to the state, before a single dollar of commission.
Who Pays the Mansion Tax
The mansion tax applies to residential purchases of $1 million or more, and it is paid by the buyer. Statewide, it starts at 1% of the full price. In New York City, the rate climbs in tiers as prices rise, reaching up to 3.9% at the very top of the market.
Sellers do not write that check, though it still affects them. Buyers shopping just above $1 million often push back on price to offset the tax, so homes priced at $1,025,000 can sit while a listing at $995,000 draws offers. Your agent should talk through that line with you before you set a list price.
New York City sales of $3 million and up also carry a higher state transfer tax rate on residential property. If your apartment falls in that range, have your attorney run the exact numbers.
Co-op and Condo Board Packages
Most Manhattan apartments that come up for sale are co-ops, and the board approval process adds real work to every sale. The buyer has to submit a board package with tax returns, bank statements, reference letters, and a detailed financial statement. Then the board interviews them and can reject the sale without giving a reason.
Your listing agent's fee in the city usually covers helping the buyer's side assemble that package and keeping it moving. A sloppy package can delay a closing by weeks. Ask any agent you interview how many board packages they have pushed through in your building or ones like it.
Extra Seller Costs in Buildings
Co-op sellers often face a flip tax set by the building, commonly 1% to 3% of the sale price, though some buildings charge a flat fee or a per-share amount. There are also managing agent fees, stock transfer stamps, and lien search charges. Condo sellers skip the flip tax in most cases but still pay processing fees to the building.
None of these are commission, yet they come out of the same proceeds. Get the building's fee schedule from the managing agent before you price the unit.
Attorneys Run the Closing
New York is an attorney state for residential closings in practice. Both buyer and seller almost always hire a real estate attorney, and the attorneys negotiate and draft the contract after the agents reach a deal on price and terms. That step is where inspection issues, closing dates, and contingencies get settled.
Seller attorney fees vary by region. Upstate, flat fees often fall somewhere around $1,000 to $2,000, while New York City attorneys handling co-op and condo sales commonly charge more, often $2,500 to $5,000 or above. Some sellers ask their agent for referrals, which is common and fine as long as you compare a couple of options.
Ways to Lower What You Pay
Negotiating commission works best when you bring specifics. Sellers with homes likely to sell fast, such as a well-priced split-level in a strong Long Island school district or a renovated condo near a subway line, have the most leverage. A home that needs work or sits in a slow pocket of the Southern Tier gives the agent more risk, and they will price that in.
These approaches tend to work in New York:
- Interview three agents and ask each for their listing fee in writing, separate from any buyer-agent contribution.
- Offer a tiered fee, such as a lower rate if the home sells within 30 days or above a target price.
- Ask whether the fee drops if the agent also represents the buyer, if that arrangement is allowed at their firm.
- Negotiate the buyer-agent contribution offer by offer instead of committing to a fixed number upfront.
Discount and flat-fee brokerages operate across the state, especially in the city and on Long Island. They can save you money, but check what you lose. Some do not attend showings or handle board packages, which can cost more in time than you save in fees.
Sample Commission Math
| Sale Price | Location | Total Fee at 5% | Listing Side at 2.5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| $275,000 | Syracuse area | $13,750 | $6,875 |
| $650,000 | Nassau County | $32,500 | $16,250 |
| $1,100,000 | Brooklyn condo | $55,000 | $27,500 |
| $2,500,000 | Manhattan co-op | $125,000 | $62,500 |
These figures are examples only. Your rates depend on what you negotiate and whether you agree to cover the buyer's agent.
Picking an Agent in New York
Look for someone who sells in your specific market. A top Westchester agent may not know how to handle a Harlem co-op board, and a Manhattan specialist may not know the quirks of a lake house in the Finger Lakes. Track record in your building, town, or zip code matters more than brand name.
You can compare local professionals through our real estate agent directory pages, and browse more selling tips on our blog before your first listing appointment. Bring your questions about commission, buyer-agent contributions, and marketing plans in writing so every agent answers the same ones.
FAQ
Is 6% still standard in New York?
There is no standard rate, and many New York sellers now pay a total closer to 5% or less. The listing side alone often runs around 2.5% to 3%, with the buyer-agent fee negotiated separately since August 2024.
Do sellers pay the mansion tax in NYC?
No. The buyer pays the mansion tax on residential purchases of $1 million or more, starting at 1% and rising to 3.9% at the top tier in the city. Sellers do pay the state and city transfer taxes.
Do I need an attorney to sell a house upstate?
New York law does not technically require one, but nearly every residential sale in the state uses attorneys on both sides. Upstate seller attorney fees often fall around $1,000 to $2,000 for a standard house sale.
Can a co-op board reject my buyer after we sign?
Yes. Most co-op contracts are contingent on board approval, and boards can decline without explaining why. A strong board package and a buyer with solid post-closing liquidity, often one to two years of maintenance in reserve, lower that risk.