🏡 Official Rankings
10 Best Real Estate Agents in Middletown, NY (August 2026)
We compared 10 real estate agents serving Middletown and Orange County, New York, and ranked the top agents by verified reviews, ratings, and local reputation — 994 customer reviews in all.
The 10 listed below hold an average rating of 5.0 out of 5, led by Brian Caplicki. Updated for August 2026.
- Real Estate Agents ranked
- 10
- Average rating
- 5.0★
- Reviews analyzed
- 994
- Area codes
- 845, 732
Brian Caplicki
Keller Williams Hudson Valley United
⭐ 4.9 · 29 reviews
Laurel Lustgarten
HOWARD HANNA | RAND REALTY
⭐ 5.0 · 167 reviews
John J Lease REALTORS
John J. Lease Realtors, Inc.
⭐ 5.0 · 149 reviews
Susan C Giordano
John J Lease REALTORS
⭐ 5.0 · 114 reviews
Dominick Tufano
REMAX Benchmark Realty Group
⭐ 5.0 · 120 reviews
Hudson Valley Home Connection
Hudson Valley Home Connection, LLC
⭐ 5.0 · 176 reviews
Christopher Ogden - REALTOR
Realty Promotions, Inc.
⭐ 5.0 · 91 reviews
Edwin Rodriguez - Sales
Keller Williams Realty HVU
⭐ 5.0 · 42 reviews
Tom Pahucki
Keller Williams Realty
⭐ 5.0 · 56 reviews
Anita Cristiano
HomeSmart Homes and Estates
⭐ 4.9 · 50 reviews
Real Estate Agents listed here serve Middletown, Orange County, and nearby ZIP codes including 10940, 10941, 10943.