🏡 Official Rankings

10 Best Real Estate Agents in Orange County, NY (September 2026)

We compared 10 real estate agents serving Orange County, New York, and ranked the top agents by verified reviews, ratings, and local reputation — 1,342 customer reviews in all.

The 10 listed below hold an average rating of 5.0 out of 5, led by Brian Caplicki. Updated for September 2026.

Real Estate Agents ranked: 10
Average rating: 5.0★
Reviews analyzed: 1,342
Area code: 845

Brian Caplicki

Keller Williams Hudson Valley United

⭐ 4.9 · 29 reviews

875 homes sold$400K avg. sale27 yrs experience

Visit Website →

Donna Gennaro

HOWARD HANNA | RAND REALTY

⭐ 5.0 · 195 reviews

Laurel Lustgarten

HOWARD HANNA | RAND REALTY

⭐ 5.0 · 167 reviews

442 homes sold$502K avg. sale23 yrs experience

Visit Website →

Rosalie Cook

Weichert Realtors

⭐ 4.9 · 147 reviews

711 homes sold$551K avg. sale24 yrs experience

Visit Website →

Hudson Valley Home Connection

Hudson Valley Home Connection, LLC

⭐ 5.0 · 176 reviews

895 homes sold$394K avg. sale36 yrs experience

DONNA BRUNELL

The Brunell Team @ RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group

⭐ 5.0 · 128 reviews

801 homes sold$446K avg. sale23 yrs experience

Visit Website →

John J Lease REALTORS

John J. Lease Realtors, Inc.

⭐ 5.0 · 149 reviews

1,824 homes sold$384K avg. sale88 yrs experience

Visit Website →

JENNIFER DICOSTANZO

RE/MAX Town & Country

⭐ 5.0 · 123 reviews

Richard Froehlich

RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group

⭐ 5.0 · 107 reviews

#10

Griffith Realtors

⭐ 5.0 · 121 reviews